US version of Equestria girls is better

Uninspired thinly veiled cash grab with horrible writing and art style
 
A highly demanded professionally made passion project and while the anime look IS generic at least is pleasing to the eye.

Uninspired thinly veiled cash grab with horrible writing and art style
 
A highly demanded professionally made passion project and while the anime look IS generic at least is pleasing to the eye.

plz starswill academy was a great demo

@Background Pony #E940  
Essentially.

@Background Pony #A623  
So funny, I forgot to laugh.

@somercet  
Didn’t you understand how Character designs are NOT important?

@Millennial Dan  
tl;dr  
Everyone has opinions.

@PonyPon  
In a significant sense, none of us are perfectly objective. We can try to be so, but in matters of art, it becomes an almost impossible task. That’s why you see a lot of people attempting to make value-based judgments, like “Flash is a bland character.” Being bland or boring is as impossible a concept to agree on as the distinction between a pile and a heap. Objective arguments would be something like, “The animation had a lot of errors,” or “Sunset Shimmer was an evil person.” We can define those aspects very tidily, but we can’t say that the movie was good or bad based on those completely objective observations, because they vary in importance to different people.

@Millennial Dan  
So, are you saying it’s nigh impossible to judge this movie objectively and come out with a negative overall view?

@PonyPon  
Yeah, but that reasoning tends to rely entirely on matters of personal opinion. Perceived “plot holes”, for example. Logical problems srping up frequently in the show, but the backlash against it is disproportionately worse for Equestria Girls. So, individual taste must, in my estimation, be primarily to blame.

@Millennial Dan  
So, is it possible to have seen and hated the film without some kind of fallacy backing it?

@AdamTheHedgehog  
No it isn’t. The execution was fine. All I ever hear people saying whining about is that it’s set in a high school, features humans, Twilight has a crush, blah blah on it goes. Many people even make factually incorrect statements about the film, and I don’t know if that’s because of a negative perception filter, poor memory, or the fact that they’re just lying about having seen it. Propbably a little of all the above.

It’s the execution that a lot of people hate more than the concept itself.

THAT MEANS 3 VERSIONS. HALO 3 CONFIRMED. HOENN WAS GEN 3. HOENN CONFIRMED. (?)

I liked EG and like where Star is going so far.  
I prefer Star’s graphics more but EG is canon and fits the universe of mlp better. that does not mean ithink EG was bad unlike a few fans

@Kanrabat  

@SunsetShimmer
 

@Trachyon  
Way to get butthurt over an obvious troll.

@Background Pony #549F  
Sorry. I’m just snappy today. Especially towards absurd generalisations. Nobody take it personally.

@Trachyon  
Don’t be a jerk. It’s not like we haven’t seen the exact opposite opinion around here.

@SunsetShimmer  
Welcome to the City of Opinions. You have been appointed mayor of the City of Opinions. Nobody lives in the City of Opinions except you, and there is nothing in the City of Opinions except you.
 
Thank you for voicing your opinion in the City of Opinions.

@chaos15  
A rare gem, that show.
 
I agree with Sunset though, EqG’s style is pretty cute.

@SunsetShimmer  
Shut the hell up Sunset. You are only jealous because you are not in Starswirl Academy.
 
Now have some Cowboy Beebop  
 
 
 

I’m just gonna say it.  
Equestria Girls is cute as fuck and anime sucks.