Viewing last 25 versions of comment by Beau Skunky on image #2514188

Beau Skunky
Friendship, Art, and Magic (2019) - Celebrated Derpibooru's seventh year anniversary with friends
Cool Crow - "Caw!" An awesome tagger
Magnificent Metadata Maniac - #1 Assistant
Artist -

Rub my belly!
"[@Background Pony #A4A7":](/images/2514188#comment_9426519
)  
I don't think the original story did, one of the first adaptations that even hinted at "Hell/damnation" was the Disney Christmas Carol, where a terrified Scrooge McDuck sees burning fire coming out of his open coffin. Then it kinda became a common trope for "A Christmas Carol/Scrooge" adaptations afterwards.

"

 
[
@Background Pony Number 17":](/images/2514188#comment_9424911
)  
Yeah, I can understand that too, and honestly merely "charging rent" is not the worst thing for a person to do.


 
I also don't get why Filthy is always cast as the typical "evil Rich guy" by the fanbase, as in the actual show, he's been shown to be actually a nice guy, (probably the only "nice" wealthy/upper-crust character besides Fancy Pants) a fair/generous businessman, and his daughter genuinely loves/respects him. (One of Tiara's only redeeming factors in her pre-reformation episodes.)
 
In fact, I didn't like how EqGirls "Camp Everfree" made him an antagonist, (even making his human design look meaner) and while granted that was a different A.U. "Filthy Rich," it seems to of been enough for fans to be convinced his pony counterpart is somehow a bad person too.


 
Not accusing this artist of thinking that, as I don't know their intentions, but it seems common with many other fanartists.
No reason given
Edited by Beau Skunky
Beau Skunky
Friendship, Art, and Magic (2019) - Celebrated Derpibooru's seventh year anniversary with friends
Cool Crow - "Caw!" An awesome tagger
Magnificent Metadata Maniac - #1 Assistant
Artist -

Rub my belly!
"@Background Pony #A4A7":/images/2514188#comment_9426519
I don't think the original story did, one of the first adaptations that even hinted at "Hell/damnation" was the Disney Christmas Carol, where a terrified Scrooge McDuck sees burning fire coming out of his open coffin. Then it kinda became a common trope for "A Christmas Carol/Scrooge" adaptations afterwards.

"@Background Pony Number 17":/images/2514188#comment_9424911
Yeah, I can understand that too, and honestly merely "charging rent" is not the worst thing for a person to do.

I also don't get why Filthy is always cast as the typical "evil Rich guy" by the fanbase, as in the actual show, he's been shown to be actually a nice guy, (probably the only "nice" wealthy/upper-crust character besides Fancy Pants) a fair/generous businessman, and his daughter genuinely loves/respects him. (One of Tiara's only redeeming factors in her pre-reformation episodes.)
In fact, I didn't like how EqGirls "Camp Everfree" made him an antagonist, (even making his human design look meaner) and while granted that was a different A.U. "Filthy Rich," it seems to of been enough for fans to be convinced his pony counterpart is somehow a bad person too.

Not accusing this artist of thinking that, as I don't know their intentions.
No reason given
Edited by Beau Skunky
Beau Skunky
Friendship, Art, and Magic (2019) - Celebrated Derpibooru's seventh year anniversary with friends
Cool Crow - "Caw!" An awesome tagger
Magnificent Metadata Maniac - #1 Assistant
Artist -

Rub my belly!
"@Background Pony #A4A7":/images/2514188#comment_9426519
I don't think the original story did, one of the first adaptations that even hinted at "Hell/damnation" was the Disney Christmas Carol, where a terrified Scrooge McDuck sees burning fire coming out of his open coffin. Then it kinda became a common trope for "A Christmas Carol/Scrooge" adaptations afterwards.

"@Background Pony Number 17":/images/2514188#comment_9424911
Yeah, I can understand that too, and honestly merely "charging rent" is not the worst thing for a person to do.

I also don't get why Filthy is always cast as the typical "evil Rich guy" by the fanbase, as in the actual show, he's been shown to be actually a nice guy, (probably the only "nice" wealthy/upper-crust character besides Fancy Pants) a fair/generous businessman, and his daughter genuinely loves/respects him. (One of Tiara's only redeeming factors in her pre-reformation episodes.)
In fact, I didn't like how EqGirls "Camp Everfree" made him an antagonist, (even making his human design look meaner) and while granted that was a different A.U. "Filthy Rich," it seems to of been enough for fans to be convinced his pony counterpart somehow a bad person too.
No reason given
Edited by Beau Skunky