Uploaded by PaperBagPony 
3067x2218 PNG 940 kB
Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!
Description
Oh dear!!…. i can’t believe it! Senpai noticed me!! O ///// C ///// O”
Dude, you did bother her with why she should take off her bag, but have you asked WHY she wears it?
Already done, got the answer I expected. Disappointed in it, but it is what it is.
Could you please stop?
It’s true, I lost my ability to fly when I was unmasked. …Never really used it much anyways.
@Background Pony #330C
Dude, stop pestering the Bag pony so much. If she took off her bag, then she wouldn’t be the Bag Pony anymore, and would just be “The Pony.”
(Besides, practically every pony looks the same anyways, if you’re that curious of what she looks like, just look at every other pony OC. At least the paper bag is cute & comical.)
I’m actually having fun with your circling reasoning here. Because so far you’re still attempting to explain that it’s simply: I don’t want to.
Insofar I’ve already gave proper logical arguments and counterpoints to things you’ve disputed so far. Right now you’re just going with an ad hominem by thinking I’m bothered by it when it’s the opposite. I’ve already put out a counterpoint as to why well known superheroes with masked identities would be unmasked with the Batman example.
You on the other hand have yet to give an actual debunk to my claim of: “I don’t want to unmask my OC” other than just that - is it a valid reason? Technically it is since it’s your creation. But you still approached a mischaracterization poorly regardless. And you know what, if you wanted to specifically state that it’s the only reason why. Then you should just make become a disclaimer or even a mission statement for your OC to prevent further instances of this happening.
Oh and I know I won’t change your mind, but I find it entertaining that something as simple as me expressing an opinion (a semi popular one at that) is enough to rankle you with what constitutes to be more of an emotional response than a logical reason to those requests. I guess all it took was a little nudge and someone willing to engage into a conversation or even a debate if you’re willing to go that far to acknowledge the only person to blame in this is you. You created the OC the way she is, you gave others like myself the curiosity to request to unmask her (no one forced you or put a gun to your head or anything of the sort - you came to that conclusion yourself when I said the word: should, never demanded it, but suggested it, and it wasn’t even in proper context of who’s doing the unmasking the OC’s creator or Sweet Velvet in the picture). In the end, it boils down to: If you can’t stand the heat, stay out of the kitchen.
Edited because: removed double quote
yeah, what it bothers me are you reasons of why i should have to (just because Batman had a reason to, it means that i need to have a reason too?)
and you still giving reasons because a simple ’ i don’t want to’ it bothers you and it’s not a valid argument to you
and of course it bothers you, if it were not the case, you would stop giving me your reasons and haven’t done the assumption that my design it’s just because ‘i want to straight up’
at least i’m being honest, and say i’m still defending myself (at least i think i’m) because you’re still bothering me with your ‘reasons’ that for this point, must be clear you won’t change my mind… but you still trying
And yet they still get unmasked (albeit rarely), along Batman and others, but due to deus ex machina and editorial mandates by higher ups to keep things in check and keep the status quo ongoing. Pretty much one of the latest and best examples used recently in superhero comics was Batman unmasking himself as Bruce Wayne in front of Jim Gordon at the end of Batman: White Knight limited series (excellent short series to read as well) due to Batman nearly losing himself in the rage and vengeance but finally trying to make himself more accountable to Gotham and the people he cares for.
Oh and to clarify on my first comment here as to who ‘she’ was in she should. I meant Sweet Velvet due to that mischievous look on her face, I will apologize that you misunderstood the intent of who I wanted to do the unmasking in context of this specific picture, but that’s it. Do I think you should eventually try to do an unmasking of your character? Yes, that’s just my opinion and I already explained myself to it. For the time being you don’t want to and that’s your call. But who’s to say one day you’ll change your mind as well.
I also don’t see how it bothers me. If anything I think it bothered you due to originally a lack of clarification on my part which lead you to get overly defensive about your character’s identity which has already been requested multiple times over by other people. I’ve yet to see anything other than a cohesive rebuttal/counter-argument within logical foundations to say exactly why you chose not to unmask her other than: I don’t want to.
Actually I’m enjoying writing these blocks of text up because seeing you scramble for something and posting it here is almost me baiting you which isn’t even intended. But keep going please.
Edited
Oh! so it bothers you!… now it makes sense
Edited
You’re not the first one who mention a ‘face reveal’, but you’re the first one on say ‘YOU SHOULD’… like if i’m obligated or i owed you that… and that’s rude for me
usually people do understand when i say no, but you’re the first one on give me ‘reasons’
Spiderman it’s not going to do a face reveal just because the citizens, the police, his enemies, ask him to
Powers of being lewd I guess? Well at least that’s a half-baked enough reason that I could even somewhat accept if it was the case. But I don’t think it is. Seems moreso of the artist just wanting to straight up.
The Unmasking trope
I already explained MY reasoning, and it can be reasoning others may share in different degrees or ratios. It’s your OC and you’re not being forced to do anything here. But maybe a little self awareness in that how people who like and enjoy your character would like to see her ‘unmasked’ rather than basically disregarding someone just explaining their rationale. How you replied to me when I tried explaining my side of things was rude, and no I don’t want or expect an apology. But I’ll call you out on it.
Let’s be honest, you created this can of worms by making your character’s design exactly what it is. You’re going to ignore human nature via curiosity to wonder what lies underneath the bag? As I said, your character your prerogative. Cool, we’ll keep it at that. Just don’t get overly defensive if people in the future still request to see the bag removed and the OC unmasked.
Paper Bag is extremely cute! I’d cuddle with her anytime!
After saying this, of course i am… like why ‘I SHOULD’ have to?
Yikes, way to get all defensive about it.
sorry dear, but i don’t care if you’re half-agree with me
i’m not going to and i don’t have to take off my bag, and none of you can force me
I’m 50/50 on that, the mystery of seeing what’s underneath the bag is fun. But when that reveal happens, then there goes the mystique of it all too. So I can both agree and disagree with your stance.
Okay cutie! ^^
but i don’t want to show it :C and i don’t want to be forced
besides, wearing my bag makes me be Paper Bag!
But we want to see your face, cutie.
no, it’s not canon
and no, i don’t have to >:C
Edited