Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Play Battle Gem Ponies on Mobile or PC

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

The fact they just kinda randomly pick which ending is “canon” is really confusing.  
Could’ve leave it up to interpretations…  
Like showing Shining City moving without using any methods from All the World’s Off Stage.  
Showcasing any scenes in the slide show from the “beginning” of any CYOA shorts in Happily Ever After Party instead of the endings.
 
IMO, this is not how you should approach CYOAs. Your choices should be contained inside one short. If you need it to have some consequences down the road, just make it one short with a decision tree.

safe2285819 apple bloom62460 applejack208934 fluttershy269268 pinkie pie267249 rainbow dash291733 all the world's off stage263 all the world's off stage: twilight sparkle47 constructive criticism236 constructive criticism: pinkie pie50 constructive criticism: rainbow dash65 equestria girls268661 g42127221 happily ever after party353 happily ever after party: applejack65 happily ever after party: rainbow dash74 happily ever after party: rarity167 my little pony equestria girls: better together40992 opening night300 broken hand43 clothes681228 coal miner122 costume42249 drum kit408 drums1537 geode of sugar bombs2714 geode of super speed3146 geode of super strength2936 goggles19630 headlamp267 helmet17158 high res412049 magical geodes12342 mining helmet646 musical instrument16258 overalls2820
Source

Comments

Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ ~sub~

Detailed syntax guide

skilledful

@Gian Song Yim  
I would like Equestria Girls to continue after G4, in a series of 22 minutes for each episode.With each episode involving a self-contained story(Daily Life and Villain of The Week) while contributing to a larger storyline(Big Bad of the season)
Gian~
Wallet After Summer Sale -

EG Enthusiast
@Background Pony #A473  
full  
full  
Yeah, I didn’t include all of the endings appearing in other shorts.  
Still doesn’t change what I said tho…  
The fact they just kinda randomly pick which ending is “canon” is really confusing.
Could’ve leave it up to interpretations…
Like showing Shining City moving without using any methods from All the World’s Off Stage.
Showcasing any scenes in the slide show from the “beginning” of any CYOA shorts in Happily Ever After Party instead of the endings.
IMO, this is not how you should approach CYOAs. Your choices should be contained inside one short. If you need it to have some consequences down the road, just make it one short with a decision tree.
Background Pony #68C6
Hold it! In the Rainbow Dash ending of Happily Ever After Party; we can see slides of the Photo Finish ending of Constructive Criticism, and the Pinkie Pie and Micro Chips endings for All the World’s Off Stage.
Background Pony #46C3
@Background Pony #E223  
That doesn’t make any sense when there are relatively important events like Sunset passing her driving test  
And there’s nothing that would really suggest non-canonicity like the bloopers have
Background Pony #F2E5
I think the CYOA series in the same vain as the bloopers reels  
So none of it is canon technically