@19-2000  
I don’t see the harm in them either. I’m just telling you why some people probably don’t like it.

@Background Pony #A0D7  
I just don’t see the harm in fat humanizations. Or any kind of humanizations, really. It’s literally not hurting anyone else, and it’s just how the artist sees Pinkie Pie as a human.
 
Plus, most of the female pony characters on the show have the exact same body type since it is a cartoon and they are literal ponies, and I don’t think they would all have the exact same body type if they were humans.
 
But that’s just my opinion; if someone else can see them all having the same body type, that’s fine. I just don’t see why some people complain when a humanization doesn’t fit their exact vision.

@19-2000  
I think the thing is, in the show Pinkie isn’t heavy, at all. I know all the mane six have the same Flash body model and all that, but… there are chubby ponies in the show, like Mrs Cake. I get headcanon and artistic interpretation and all that, but Pinkie in the show isn’t heavier than her friends, and since we know fat and chubby ponies exist, there’s no reason to believe Pinkie is.

its almost as if fat people exist or something wow

Why is Pinkie fat as fuck

I can’t see Dash wearing makeup like that either. And, we know from her pony form she has longer hair (Scoots’ human hairstyle would probably be like that). Good enough otherwise though.
 
One question though, why do they all have show accurate hair colors but Fluttershy?

Personally, I like humanized Pinkies who resemble a young Nanny Ogg. It feels appropriate.

Pinkie is too fat and Rainbow has too many tatoos. Except for that, this picture is perfect.