@Background Pony #2942  

@Background Pony #2942  
Reply to ancient comments sum moar.

@TexasUberAlles  
cry sum moar

@Kolbjorn  
switch 2 and 3 and I think we’ll have Equestria’s history so fare

Ok, lets see if this make sense:  
1.- The ponies Found Equestria, Star Swirl was working for the king of Unicornia.  
2.- Scorpan and Tirek come to Equestria, Scorpan befirends Star Swirl, he knew that the normal ponies cant defeat his brother so he goes to Luna and Celestia, they are already alicorns but dont rule equestria.  
3.- Discord comes out of nowhere, takes over Equestria, get his ass stoned and the ponies decide that Luna and celestia should rule them  
4.- They banish Sombra  
5.- Luna goes nuts

My Little Pony, Friendship is Magic is complicated.  
Canonicalism what is that?  
Either way I hope season 5 has lots of quality and fun.

@Ninoyiya  
Good point!

@Background Pony #E2CD
 
I like to think that Celestia thinks of everyone as a young one.

@Ninoyiya  
Funny how Celestia called him a “young unicorn”.
 
Something doesn’t add up here.

@SeraphimDawn
 
Apparently he just kind of went back home.

@Ninoyiya  
What happened to FiM Scorpan? Did he die of age or something?

@SeraphimDawn
 
It all really depends on how old Star Swirl was during Hearth’s Warming Eve.
 
If he was young enough during that time then he could have easily met Scorpan later on in his life during the rule of Celestial Sisters.

@Ninoyiya  
Star Swirl the Bearded was supposed to be Clover the Clever’s mentor, right? The events of Hearthwarming Eve allegedly predated the Celestial Sisters’ rule over Equestria. Had Scorpan been friends with SSB, and met with the Celestial Sisters, he would’ve lived for quite awhile. Right?

@SeraphimDawn
 
Scorpan lived long enough?

@Sr Pelusa  
no

Now I’m having difficulties trying to put all this into context with the scenarios of Hearthwarming Eve. Either Scorpan lived long enough to meet the Celestial Sisters, or they’ve completely retconned the founding of Equestria from HWE.

I’d want to see twilights reaction to discord being her idle.

Star Swirl is Discord

Discord and Tirek both have seats on the council of evil.

interesting ideas,  
i did think something along those lines.