Policy Update - Rules changes incoming for AI content - Read Here
Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Ministry of Image - Fanfiction Printing

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

In just over a month, Past Sins will be 10 years old.  
Tags taken from the cover art image.

safe2270511 artist:valcron348 apple bloom62277 applejack208204 fluttershy269394 nightmare moon21485 pinkie pie266160 princess celestia117134 princess luna121847 rainbow dash291159 rarity226073 scootaloo60615 sweetie belle58699 twilight sparkle371717 oc1000116 oc:nyx2610 alicorn336648 pony1703248 unicorn583019 fanfic:past sins417 g42129461 abuse10656 adventure in the comments1353 applejack's hat16305 armor33080 bandage8308 batty gloom1 bed63252 brony history384 butt250206 cape15561 cell284 chains7555 clothes680057 cmc cape323 comments locked down544 cowboy hat28264 crying58187 cuffs6849 cutie mark crusaders23150 derp8680 dungeon1408 element of generosity1510 element of honesty1496 element of kindness1680 element of laughter1526 element of loyalty1716 element of magic3764 elements of harmony2966 ethereal mane15018 execution532 eye contact7862 fandom history3 fanfic11533 fanfic art19598 fanfic cover1708 frown38539 gallows89 glare9185 glowing eyes16394 glowing horn31183 gritted teeth20712 hairband2478 hanging (by neck)714 hat133648 headband6033 horn243650 implied trixie493 looking at each other38449 magic102063 manacles139 memories262 nightmare nyx134 no cutie marks yet67 noose606 past sins tenth anniversary7 pen stroke13 plot155345 raised hoof76294 silhouette3556 smiling432795 spread wings106046 stetson6134 telekinesis41408 twilybuse932 two sides454 unicorn twilight37746 vest6679 wings250605 x eyes993
Source

Comments

Background Pony #1601
Deletion reason: Rule #6: Off-topic complaining about enforcement of off-topic rules
GenericArchangel
Alicorn Squadron - For supporting the site
Nightmare in the Moon - Had their OC in the 2024 Derpibooru Collab.
Pixel Perfection - I still call her Lightning Bolt
Solar Supporter - Fought against the New Lunar Republic rebellion on the side of the Solar Deity (April Fools 2023).
Princess of Love - Extra special version for those who participated in the Canterlot Wedding 10th anniversary event by contributing art.
Artist -
Elements of Harmony - Had an OC in the 2022 Community Collab
Non-Fungible Trixie -
Preenhub - We all know what you were up to this evening~
Twinkling Balloon - Took part in the 2021 community collab.

Free the Tantabus
Okay y’all, this discussion has moved beyond being relevant to the image, which is merely noting that the fanfic Past Sins will be ten years old next month. This sort of discussion of merits of it vs the show and of certain characters is much better suited to our forums, particularly the Unpopular Opinion thread in the Pony forums.
 
Thanks y’all.
Background Pony #1601
@SombodyElse  
Most people will use any excuse to hate on Nyx or Past Sins because “it’s an alicorn oc” or “i hate mary sues”
 
When since Season 1, the show has added at least 3 more alicorns. And despite complaints about the fanfiction writing characters “out of character” it has done a fairly good job at portraying how characters would act in situations before the show did. Things like Zecora being the central storyteller for a Ponyville festival, like Nightmare Night, or how when Twilight is under pressure she fails to inform her mentor out of fear. Which happened in Lesson Zero.
 
That’s not mentioning the whole thing of people slapping her with the term “Mary Sue” while giving Starlight a free pass because “Well Starlight is canon so it’s ok when they do it.”
Beltar
Duck - User has been known to often resemble a waterfowl

@Background Pony #1601
 
This is very strange allegation considering that Nyx is the only OC with significant fan-base and “Past Sins” is the only English-language fan-fic which I think is real literature.
 
In 2021, its laughably cliche
 
In 2021 bronies can’t create anything like that because they lost any sence of MLP itself. In fact they can’t create anything except copying season 1 ideas.
 
And literally everything uses some cliche because cliche works. The only problem it’s not so easy to use it right.
 
And yes “Past Sins” is very close to MLP itself with only few rule changings. In fact it’s MLP Advanced Version.
Background Pony #1601
the irony is most people hate past sins, yet love the show when it does the same tropes.
Background Pony #5BBF
One month??? It can’t have taken just one month to pen a full-length novel!