Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Ministry of Image - Fanfiction Printing

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

extracted by request

safe2266261 artist:hellpony36 derpibooru exclusive43543 cozy glow10252 princess celestia116962 alicorn335640 pegasus536006 pony1698515 g42125939 a better ending for cozy255 adopted524 adoption273 awww250 cozybetes1512 cozylove91 cropped62881 cute279850 cutelestia4436 daaaaaaaaaaaw7637 duo204245 eyes closed147711 female1907563 filly104859 foal53331 forgiveness279 harsher in hindsight518 heartwarming1100 heartwarming in hindsight155 hug39673 if only135 love7002 momlestia1158 momlestia fuel138 mother and child7078 mother and daughter9142 parent:princess celestia2918 redemption181 reformation84 reformed villain187 simple background638237 sweet dreams fuel2248 transparent background300157 what if766
Source

Comments

Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide

Background Pony #5172
@Ohvist
A lot of that is practically assumption, especially everything you had to say about Nightmare Moon
Posted Report
Background Pony #478E
if be the mother of Cozy, trust me she be a better filly, sure be a bit like sunset as her first but be guide in the right path!
Ohvist

@Background Pony #090C  
It’s not that I love Luna that makes me hate Celestia as you seem to put it, it’s more to do with how seemingly ungodly perfect she is decried as being without showing much in the way of regret, apologetic repentance, or seeking to make any amends or accepting the blame for her own mistakes. If she did care enough about her sister when she had fallen, than why would she leave her trapped on the Moon for 1000 years in the first place; especially when she had the power all along to release her any time she wished?
 
full
 
The only reason why Luna fell was due to sheer loneliness and feeling that she wasn’t appreciated or loved enough by their subjects, in many ways even her own sister seemed to continuously ignore her; a fact that hasn’t gotten any better at all with the way that the government was now restructured to solely work around Celestia leaving Luna without anything of her own; not even a throne until season 8. Even Nightmare Night is just one big insult directed towards Luna by constantly demonizing her alter-ego and painting her as a foal-eating monster that terrorizes children unless she is appeased with candy, not even spending a moment within the 1000 years to help the public differentiate Luna from Nightmare Moon, or even trying to leave any details about Luna in the history books that are available to the wider public.
 
♪All your faith in ancient ways,♫
♪leaves you trapped inside a Maze.♫
 
Even after Luna was released, Celestia didn’t try to confront her on her own or even try to make any apology for what SHE did to her. Even after Twilight and her friends used the elements on Luna and Celestia showed up; she didn’t act like a sister who made a mistake and wanted to make amends, she simply demanded for Luna to accept her friendship without saying that she was even remotely wrong for what she did. And to make things even worse, she simply considered using her own sister as a punching bag for Twilight to begin her journey to becoming their replacement as rulers of Equestria.
 
♪Take the lives of those you need,♫
♪Sow the Death and Reap the Seed.♫
 
The fact that Sunset Shimmer was once Celestias’ apprentice before she took in Twilight implied that originally Celestia was trying to groom Sunset to become their replacement in ruling Equestria, however unlike Twilight who slowly became willing to accept any and all orders from Celestia at face-value, Sunset was more intuitive and determined often seeking power for the sake that its an option available to her. In many ways Sunset would have easily and readily became an Alicorn. However Celestia kept holding her back and placing more and more restrictions on her to keep her in check. Eventually this reached a breaking point where Sunset ran away and refused to work with Celestia: possibly discovering exactly what Celestia was setting her up for.
 
♪You can’t have my Life.♫
♪I’m not your Sacrifice.♫
♪You can try, but I’m free.♫
♪And you won’t conquer me.♫
♪I won’t crawl, most of all.♫
♪I won’t fall… for… you.♫
 
Then there is the ultimate rationale behind Celestia’s actions: is making Twilight Sparkle the new sole ruler of Equestria even worth it? Is this the path that is for the good of Equestria or good for her alone? To have damaged and destroyed her own family in such unapologetic ways; to the point where her sister was forgotten for 1000 years, where her own daughter is encased in stone for eternity, and where Twilight is blissfully unaware of the Princess of the Sun whom she has seen as a second mother and mentor is nothing more than a control freak that has slowly manipulated every single aspect of Twilights’ life because of a supposed “Destiny” implanted into the crystalline trunk of the Tree of Harmony as Twilights’ Cutie Mark. Is all of this that Celestia even did worth it?
 
♪What if all the Plans you’ve made,♫
♪Were not worth the price they paid?♫
♪Even with the lives you stole,♫
♪Still no closer to your… goal…♫
nightshroud96
Lunar Supporter - Helped forge New Lunar Republic's freedom in the face of the Solar Empire's oppressive tyrannical regime (April Fools 2023).

@Background Pony #090C  
From the looks of it, Luna is still not getting the amount of appreciation Celestia has gotten even after protecting them in their dreams.  
Also, NMM wouldn’t let Equestria freeze due to she wanted her night to be love, not because she’s doing Eternal Night because “evulz”. It would contradict her goals if she allows the ponies to die, then no one would love her night.  
In fact, the NMM timeline in Cutie Re-Mark shows NMM succeeded in just that with how Equestria was just completely fine despite it being night all the time. I think NMM even mentioned its been years since she booted Celestia to the moon.
Background Pony #090C
@Ohvist  
you forget Celestia is be young and naive on the time she seal luna and she don’t have the choice to do, and is broke her heart, thanks of all her student, she a not fall the same darkness luna a fall, plus if Celestia be the mother Cozy, she will make sure Cozy rise on the good path(not make the same mistake with sunset) Cozy will a great and friendly filly who want to help and make friends, you see only the dark past of celestia, all because she seal luna, you jump on the celestia-hater train and believe all their hate and headcanon as canon and not look the good she a done, this is the problem of luna-lover, see luna as nothing but as victim and not look her wrong, Yes Luna be victim as some level but is more the faul of those who love Celestia day, but don’t forget , Celestia have a lot duty, yes she love all the love she get from the subject but she have still rule the kingdom, Luna be so young and she try to do her part but the subject be sleep when she do her duty, Luna so young not see all she could do to be love by her subject, like protect them in their dreamthis is something she do alter be reform when luna turn to nightmare moon, Celestia a try to reasoned her but she don’t lesson, Luna try to murder her own sister and make the eternal night who is a stupid plan and will kill every life from on the plant, You think is be fun for Celestia to sealing her own sister to the moon? if you say yes! you a dead wrong, she be really hurt!
Ohvist

@Background Pony #1875  
You DO realize that this is the same Celestia that sent her own kid sister to the Moon for 1000 years and had the power to return her whenever she wanted to, right? Technically speaking everything that caused Luna to fall and become Nightmare Moon is all Celestia’s fault, she screwed over her sister instead of talking things out rationally. If that’s how she treats her sister, what makes you think that she wouldn’t do something to screw over her own daughter?
Background Pony #1875
@Ohvist  
Celestia is not the mother Cozy, if she be , she will not turn her stone but lecture a lot, plus she will know is her daughter but no she don’t! You guys come crazy theory!
Ohvist

@Red-Supernova  
It wasn’t Celestia that reached out, since she was the one who originally pushed her away…  
I believe that at some point, Mother and Daughter had reconciled (likely over a holy beatdown of a greater threat that had opposed their ideals and personally-held beliefs which resulted in a near-death from the younger filly while Celestia slowly helped nurse her back to health), over time the two of them learned exactly what it felt like to have a family once again. This image was one taken before Celestia returned to Cozy Glow her natural Alicorn Magic.
Chopsticks
Cutest Little Devil - Celebrated the 14th anniversary of MLP:FIM!
Rainbow Rocks 10th Anniversary: Sonata Dusk - Celebrated the 10th anniversary of EQG Rainbow Rocks!
Celestial Glory - Helped others get their OC into the 2024 Derpibooru Collab.
Nightmare in the Moon - Had their OC in the 2024 Derpibooru Collab.
Silly Pony - Celebrated the 13th anniversary of MLP:FIM, and 40 years of MLP!
Shimmering Smile - Celebrated the 10th anniversary of Equestria Girls!
Solar Guardian - Refused to surrender in the face of the Lunar rebellion and showed utmost loyalty to the Solar Empire (April Fools 2023).
Betrayal! - Betrayed their team for a badge. Shame forever!
Crystal Roseluck - Had their OC in the 2023 Derpibooru Collab.
Flower Trio - Helped others get their OC into the 2023 Derpibooru Collab.

Rice pone
@Ohvist  
Fun as that would be, she would’ve turned out to be a terrible mother in that regard.
 
.
 
More of this “Sweet dreams fuel” tag. One day I dream to create art that is worthy of this tag.
Ohvist

@Napsack  
Why go to those lengths? Cozy and her mother are both very volatile when it comes to expending heat as shown with despite having been turned into a Pegasus, Cozy was able to instantly reach an external body temperature equivalent to 32°F easily.  
full
 
Cozy coating herself in poison would be ineffective and a waste of good poison since it would just instantly evaporate upon contact. And to openly declare yourself a villain is to know that what you are doing is wrong, but you follow through on a venture of pointless Nihilism: destruction for the sake of destruction, making a “villain” no different from a Raider.  
Besides, what kind of street cred can be ruined when your Mom is the mothabucking Sun Princess? Especially one who no longer has to hide?  
full
Napsack
Typically turned to the funny pages - For Patreon supporters
Non-Fungible Trixie -
Preenhub - We all know what you were up to this evening~
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Silver Bit -
Ruby -
Wallet After Summer Sale -
Cool Crow - "Caw!" An awesome tagger
Not a Llama - Happy April Fools Day!
Happy Derpy! - For Patreon supporters

why
For the purposes of maintaining her status as a villain, Cozy has coated herself in poison so that this hug does not cause her to lose too much of her street cred.
Ohvist

I may have already said it before elsewhere, but I believe that we can all agree on who is most-likely Cozy’s Father.  
full  
Due to the heavy presence of lighter pastels, Cozy while inheriting her Mothers’ coat would also have Sombras’ mane. And due to her veritable nature of being a child born of two parents from completely different worlds that under no circumstances would have ever met period. I am not saying that it wouldn’t apply to alternate timelines like in The Cutie Re-Mark simply because there wouldn’t be any restriction in place to prevent Celestia from wanting to bang the other worlds’ King Sombra, but it would be downright impossible for Principal Celestia to have accomplished a similar feat on her own, meaning that there is no EqG Cozy Glow that could even physically exist.