@Background Pony #D553
It rotted I think

Or it could be a copy & paste of the palantier from LOTR

Glad i’m not the only one who noticed this

Headcanon accepted!

I like universe building

@PacificSide18  
Shadow of War sounds familiar is it a video game or something and it could very well be that other things I maybe when it fell into the Ravine it died on impact sometime later groger stole the eye because of its magical properties

@PacificSide18
 
Or who read the books. 😏

It’s not called “Sauron’s Eye”, in lore this would be called the Palantir. Anyone who’s played Shadow of War recently would see the similarities.

@Phoenixflambe
 
The One and Only.
 

@DarkObsidian  
Wait, THE Gusty?

@noradtwo
 
Gusty the Great.
 

 
Seen in Princess Celestia’s flashback in My Little Pony Micro-Series Issue #8. Mentioned in A Flurry of Emotions as a character in the story Gusty the Great. She and her unicorn warriors wanted to be the first unicorns to reach Cloudsdale on foot (via the top of a mountain), but Grogar stood in their way. They combined their powers to tie him up, but he could break free. There is no more information. It looks like Gusty was successful after all. I admit, however, that I have not read the Micro series.

@Mori  
Like:  

Did he died before of after Grogar took his eye?

Who was it that Chrysalis mentioned rose up and defeated Grogar the first time?

Nice eye, Supra80! …Pun intended.

I thought the exact same thing

Nice theory but the eye would need to be a bit bigger to fit that skull

@marley  
https://i.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/facebook/000/000/262/Hypnotoad.jpg

Goats from Hell all have the same eyes. Like it could be from another Arimaspi or another goat momster altogether. Eh, I dunno, maybe. X3

I thought it looked familiar but I couldn’t place it. Might be a nice bit of universe building.

@JP  
Yeah, it probably is just Sauron’s eye Goat edition.

Honestly, I was thinking pretty much the same thing when I saw the globe (eye). Therefore, yes, I support this theory. ;-)

Seems coincidental to me, as all goat-creatures have horns like that, but interesting headcanon.

Brilliant theory!

Aw yeah! Now all he needs is his skeleton.
 
@Empress Cozy Glow  
Beats that donkey amirite?! Not you Cranky, you’re a good donkey husband.