Uploaded by Masem
768x1024 JPG 361 kBInterested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!
Description
No description provided.
Tags
+-SH safe2284854 +-SH artist:andy price3825 +-SH idw22556 +-SH cactus rose68 +-SH crystal (g4)70 +-SH marini78 +-SH medley brook70 +-SH ms. alegre13 +-SH princess celestia117797 +-SH zecora11643 +-SH abada113 +-SH kelpie911 +-SH zebra25413 +-SH friendship is magic #9032 +-SH g42141521 +-SH my little pony: friendship is magic (idw)6675 +-SH season 10540 +-SH afro904 +-SH black sclera3911 +-SH book46260 +-SH classroom2405 +-SH comic141864 +-SH desk5059 +-SH female1927677 +-SH preview2291 +-SH school2593 +-SH younger24549
Loading...
Loading...
Hear hear
It is disappointing. However, IDW is, admittedly, in a difficult spot. If they make non-pony species just like regular ponies, it comes across as boring and lazy. If they try something like new like the deer-as-elves, readers might be put off that way. Personally, however, I much prefer the second option and taking a few risks to write something more interesting.
I don’t know that ponies are that quick to point fingers they don’t have.
It’s just disappointing.
Well, to be fair, if the comics did make it some African archetype of any kind, ponies would lose their minds over the supposed inherent racism.
@xxzxxzxxzzx
That’s IDW for you.
Edited
…
That is just straight up disappointing.
ko script for the schoolroom to show an African touch. N
ko is very similar to ponish, and easily accessible on wikipedia.englishwhatever it’s dubbed inponish in the show. Zecora’s native language was made up because Lauren Faust admitted they didn’t have time to come up with authentic Swahili.Your critiques are valid, but it’s an exaggeration to say the show was that much better about it.
But unfortunately I see that Andyprice has not stopped Americanizing the comic, as there is very little that is un-American in what is far shown by # 90, do we have to have English scriptures where there are African examples that can be used? And why is the local culture so heavily toned down in favor of a clone of American society? The writers behind the TV series do not make such mistakes when portraying non-pony communities.
And; it is obvious that the author Whitley has erred. First a possible suspicion of imitation of Season 1-3 through a zebra mane 6 and harmony tree. Then contradictions like when the teacher meant “They may just be a myth” - when there is a lot of evidence that contradicts this as with the books Zecora had flipped through. Then it was thought that Zecora should be inspired by Medley Brook - thus meant that there is no African shamanism, only that it comes from Equestria. This is illogical and self-centered.
Very annoyed to see that the zebras, which should be black and white, are as colorful as the ponies - which is not necessary, thus reducing Zecora’s uniqueness which was her strength as a character in the TV series. “Monster-covered land”? Africa is the most dangerous continent after Australia for humans. There are no fewer monsters in mythological Africa than in the rest of the world.
If it’s Season 10, it’s got off to a very bad start. You must not make the rest of the world too similar to your own home as with Equestria and Zecora’s homeland.
Ouch, that knife got way too deep dude
Makes me think Zecora set up in the Everfree because it held to her expectations.
Sure sounds like Equestria alright!
Greaaaaaaaaaaaaaaat. Because that angle worked out so great in Picard.