I found “Glass of Water” more entertaining than probably I should have, though that may be due as much to the visuals as the song itself.

My favorites:
 
Smile Smile Smile  
Becoming Popular  
Apples To The Core  
Babs Seed  
Find a Pet  
The Perfect Stallion  
Generosity  
Find the Music  
The Goof Off  
The Heart Carol  
Pinkie’s Lament  
Make a Wish
 
Songs I don’t really care much for, but everyone else loves:
 
Winter Wrap-Up  
Stop the Bats  
Giggle at the Ghosties  
Hearts as Strong as Horses  
This Day Aria  
BBBFF  
Raise This Barn  
At the Gala  
What My Cutie Mark Is Telling Me  
Both Flim Flam songs

SHOO BE DOO SHOO SHOO BE DOO

…did anyone else think the seaponies might as well have had wings, a halo and light shining behind them? Or that Sonic’s drowning theme might as well have played out with dead silence afterwards when suddenly ANGELIC CHOIR? I mean, that kinda was a deus ex machinima that actually came with what could’ve passed as a choir of guardian angels.

@M3E46
 
Pretty much this

Depends on what mood I’m in. However, the CMC songs are always near the top of the list, if not actually on the top of the list.

@Ichijoe  
Right, One Bad Apple is the episode name. Meant Babs Seed.

@RaineV1  
S3? Surly that was Babs Seed? I’m not aware of any Song called Bad Apple, save the One from Use Your Illusion Pt 1.

S1: At the Gala  
S2: This Day Aria (favorite song of the series)  
S3: One Bad Apple  
S4: Bats!

@Ichijoe
 
I kind of do as well.

@Ichijoe  
Sad part is that this isn’t even a troll. I really want the Sea Ponies to get a reboot.

I want SHOO BE DOO

This Day Aria > Winter Wrap Up > Becoming popular

@cheezedoodle  
I forgot Smile…

@Ilsor
 
I want Shining Armor to get a song, dammit.

I could never pick just one.
 
S1: Winter wrap-up  
S2: Find a Pet, SSCS6k, This Day, Love’s In Bloom  
S3: MMC (the whole episode)  
S4: Apples to the Core, Glass of Water, Pinkie Pride (the whole episode), Find the Music In You

I’d have to say that my favorites are “Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000” and “This Day Aria”.

I bucking hear that SHOO BE DOO MUTHABUCK’AS!

Oh come on, the CMC song has the best instrumental version.  
Also poor Dash, she is the only character without her own song. Come on, S4 finale/S5 as a whole, do your best for the pegasus!  
And mine’s favourite is Two For the Sky.

I liked the CMC song.

>better then the theme or the CMC song  
Haha, good one Shy.