Here I go

Note: The video is no longer made for kids because of Blood and Gore

There is also nightmare at the end.

@Background Pony #3E60
have you seen “education for death?” that was also made by disney

YouTube is so awful they listed Der Fuehrer’s Face as “YouTube Kids”. That’s the infamous short where Donald Duck is in Nazi Germany (it’s a nightmare in the end). In more recent times, it was finally removed from YouTube Kids but now all the old comments have been deleted.

@Background Pony #085E  
just because its made for kids doesn’t mean its just for kids. as walt disney once said “You’re dead if you aim only for kids. Adults are only kids grown up, anyway.”

I think it’s because My Little Pony automatically means it’s kids content? That does make sense, but in this case, no it doesn’t. As far as I know, this animation is only intended for older people.

@Background Pony #91Z0
 
It’s called YouTube Premium now.

@O. Hancock  
Really… YouTube that terminates users that post that kind of stuff owned by Google have a porn version of the site? No it’s a special upgraded version of the site with many more features.

@Background Pony #91Z0  
What’s YouTube Red? Is that like YouTube’s version of a porn website???

@Background Pony #91Z0  
Yep

@Bluepenn15  
I just remembered Youtube Red users get to download videos

@Background Pony #91Z0  
Lazy

What is %&$#!*@ going on with Youtube?!

Oh my God ftc is very stupid

WE ARE CONTENT CREATORS NOT BABYSITTERS

yes this is totally for kids!! +  
all the gore and shit

@Typhoon2000  
Yeah.

@O. Hancock  
True  
COPPA is a good law, But YouTube sucks at enforcing it

@Digital Seapony
 
It is what it is. There will likely be videos from years ago on abandoned channels forever marked as “for kids” when they aren’t.
 
This is more of an abandoned channel issue than it is a COPPA issue. Some of these people probably don’t even know their passwords anymore or have good recovery options setup, and that’s the channel owner’s fault.
 
Also, some people rarely upload on YouTube and don’t actually care about managing their channels even if they haven’t totally abandoned them. I wouldn’t be surprised if some people still can log in and change their settings but are too lazy/scared to read through the information on COPPA and find out what is and isn’t for kids so they can change the settings. Those kinds of youtube channels aren’t really real content creators though. They’re either just reuploaders or people who upload more for themselves and their friends and family.
 
I still stand by my stance that in the hands of most competent YouTubers, even one with few subscribers, there are way way way worse issues on YouTube to worry about besides COPPA compliance, unless their content is actually for kids, and in that case I believe the law is good to protect kids at least in a slight amount.

Weeks later, at least one re-upload from 7 years ago is still tagged as ‘for kids’. I’d be amused if I wasn’t so horrified.

@Background Pony #1FF5  
YouTube actually did get fined by the FTC for collecting information on kids who lied about their age though. That’s literally what happened. The FTC was like, “we don’t care, you should be able to tell they were kids even though they said they weren’t 13.”

@Background Pony #1FF5  
Well that last part of 16 is fucked yeah, cause then my videos probably would be in trouble. I do primarily YouTube poops, and although my biggest demographics are equally the 18 to 24 and the 25 to whatever ages equally, I still think a lot of people would say that at least half or 2/3rds of YouTube poops would be too close to safely say they’re not for 15 year olds. There is the thing where you can only say “fuck” once in a pg-13 movie though, and if you say it more than that it’s rated R, which is for 17+. So I could just make sure to sentence mix “fuck” into all my videos at least twice, and then I’d be alright.

@O. Hancock
 
Well, as I said earlier the reason why most message boards have had the rule where users can’t be under 13 is that in order to use most message boards you have to register with an email and COPPA considers an email to be personal information. If a site knowingly allows someone under 13 to register, then they can be fined thousands for it. It has been a thing for decades
 
The key word is knowingly though. So GameFAQs, for example, will not ban someone if they found out after they were 13 that they had an account when they were under 13. They aren’t technically violating the act so they don’t care.
 
On another note, I recently seen some talk about how they want to increase the age from 13 to 16 so some are panicking over that because it would broaden that amount of content affected.