What about this?
 

I know which answer you picked hub! MONEY!

@marinus18
 
AJ looked like she was there to make a point, and only temporarily; it wasn’t her, she knew it and she wasn’t going to base life on it.  
Rarity looked like she was trying to become something that would never work out.

Applejack.  
Rarity looked indeed ‘country’ like but I wouldn’t say like applejack.

@Prof.NightJack  
I know. Pinkie outdid herself that day.

@Scrounge  
Hey now, that just makes things unfair.  
No one can beat that.

Pinkie in her Fluttershy suit.

AJ, IMHO. But it’s in the why rather than what.

I’m trying to think about the outfits, but when I reflect on that scene, my mind seems drawn to AJ wiggling her butt at the camera. How’d they get away with that?

No war in the comments?  
It’s a christmas miracle!

Aj no contest, but I loved Rarity’s droopy drawers!

AJ

When it comes to looks it was AJ all day. Rarity bordered on caricature. Not to mention AJ has experience so she can pull it off easily. Rare, not so much.
 
@Background Pony Number 17  
Well here’s the thing…that outfit, while nice is at best cowgirl formalwear and a cowgirl costume at worst; it’s flashy and not at all practical in everyday working on a farm.

AJ.  
AJ looks classy as cowgirl. Rari failed to replicate that class and just came out crude.

Rarihick! Rarihick forever, i want see mooore Rarihick draws!!!<3<3<3<3<3<3

@Background Pony Number 17  
I loved that outfit…If it was between the two, yeah, I’d choose that one. (While I love Applejack’s pampered attitude, her dress is quite…flashy.)

 
Actually, Rarity’s better when she sticks to her own vision rather than blindly copying another pony’s.

APPLEJACK! APPLEJACK! APPLEJACK!

AJ  
she looks best in both styles

Rarity.

Applejack  
OF COURSE

If it’s just the look they both do a good job of it.

Rarity’s not really wearing AJ’s look, but she’s really cute in overalls and I’d like for AJ (and Apple Bloom) to wear some at some point too

@JusticeSnake  
The show needs more of those two together. Either that, or have him interacting with Cadance a little more…Why not both.

Even Spike had eyes for AJ.  
I want see more Spike/AJ interactions.