Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Champions of Equestria

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

No description provided.

safe2267676 artist:andy price3817 idw22470 official comic7876 applejack208024 fluttershy269106 king sombra17832 pinkie pie265912 princess celestia117015 princess luna121719 rainbow dash290807 rarity225827 twilight sparkle371308 alicorn335962 pony1700330 friendship is magic #18102 g42126844 my little pony: friendship is magic (idw)6567 official14481 reflections924 spoiler:comic13619 crying58089 female1909238 frown38481 good king sombra790 looking down16178 looking up25895 male585873 mane six38933 mare806256 open mouth256995 ship:celestibra485 shipping266807 shipping war122 shitstorm66 stallion211338 straight189802 stupid sexy good king sombra17 stupid sexy sombra522 twilight sparkle (alicorn)154851 wide eyes20415
Source

Comments

Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide

Background Pony #907E
@cheezedoodle  
I wouldn’t waste your breath. I’ve been using that same argument and all I get are obsessive Celestia bronies whining about how their waifu.
toxicitzi
BUY SOME APPLES! - Derpi Supporter
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Sapphire -
Happy Derpy! - For Patreon supporters

@cheezedoodle  
makes her more human maybe, but why is that always regarded as just a good thing almost without question?
 
I’m not saying being more relatable is bad, I want characters to be relatable, but I’d also want them and their defining personalities to not be turned into play dough at the cost of more humanization, because there’s no point in them showing more human traits if none of them make any sense with each other.
 
 
@Niggoslav_Krawczyk  
are you saying that’s not entirely reasonable? you’re a effin’ pedo if you do.
cheezedoodle
Roll for Initiative - For Patreon supporters
A Lovely Nightmare Night - Celebrated the 12th anniversary of MLP:FIM!
The Power of Love - Given to a publicly verified artist with an image under their artist’s tag that has reached 1000 upvotes
Princess of Love - Extra special version for those who participated in the Canterlot Wedding 10th anniversary event by contributing art.
Non-Fungible Trixie -
Thread Starter - OC Tag Description Requests
Friendship, Art, and Magic (2020) - Took part in the 2020 Community Collab
The Magic of Friendship Grows - For helping others attend the 2020 Community Collab
Dream Come True! - Participated in the MLP 9th Anniversary Event
Silver Bit -

Moderator
TagZombie: AC15, Atk +8
@ARchy4288
 
What if I told you I liked this story because I thought it made Celestia deeper, more “human” (so to speak), and more relatable as a character?
Background Pony #907E
@ARchy4288  
As Elsa would say:
 
Let it go! Let it go!  
It’s just a kid’s show!  
Let it go! Let it go!  
No need to get butthurt!  
You need to learn  
to just roll with it.  
It’s not that major!  
The fan works are better anyway!
toxicitzi
BUY SOME APPLES! - Derpi Supporter
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Sapphire -
Happy Derpy! - For Patreon supporters

@ARchy4288  
yup. I too liked that one moment, but like I said, season 1 opener seemed to infer more things about her than just merely helping, things such as making up a plan and influencing some things for the best without actually stating what those things are. I feel season 3 tried something similar, but that one kind of blundered horribly imo, with her lesson set to being too stupid to fall for in the first place..
 
either way, yeah man, don’t worry about it. Anyone that starts anything on us will have a talk with me first, I ain’t called “toxic” for nothing.
 
full
ARchy4288

@toxicitzi  
But it started as soon as she left. She helped even when all seemed lost against discord but ever since then they’ve just treated her as more of an obstacle and a punching bag.
 
And taking a break has hardly helped because it just starts up again as soon as I come back… :( I don’t know what to do…
toxicitzi
BUY SOME APPLES! - Derpi Supporter
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Sapphire -
Happy Derpy! - For Patreon supporters

@ARchy4288  
I doubt I can answer you that mate, it could mean literally anything. Don’t let the shitty fans project your perception of the show writers as though they’re one and the same, they’re not always right about where the writers will take the show next (much as I honestly don’t like the show as of now and stopped watching it myself).
 
That’s all I can say about that, even if I don’t feel that strong about the writers. Jumping to conclusions like that is not going to do anyone any good and I’m sure it’s much more complicated than “they hate her”, because the same kinds of problems affected many of Lauren’s initial pitch ideas for the show, not all great, but most of which could have had unprecedented results, much like the show itself was an unprecedented, overwhelming success.
toxicitzi
BUY SOME APPLES! - Derpi Supporter
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Sapphire -
Happy Derpy! - For Patreon supporters

@ARchy4288  
@ARchy4288  
this is why I say you gotta relax, if you don’t you’re gonna have this kind of depression. It’s not wrong that you feel depressed over how fucking shitty the fandom can be, it’s just very bad for you and your health to do it on top of not being worth it in the slightest, because these people don’t even know they can cause this much harm with just being little assholes, they’re no psychology experts.
 
look, if you want you should get some fresh air and get your head cleared for a while, I’ve been put down myself, but I feel listening to some good music to remind me some great things that I can enjoy in my peace helps me a lot to recollect my thoughts and not break down into an angry rant sometimes, like I used to not so long ago.
ARchy4288

@toxicitzi  
“One thing that I do know is that the show will never do it, 4 years is a pretty long wait for Celestia to do not just something, but literally, Anything at all.. because even those small moments amount to absolutely nothing that can tell you more about Celestia alone, probably the only exception being the season 1 opener, where her actions seemed more focused with the narrative and how she had a hand in helping with the situation, without involving herself directly in it. Everything else after that point was her being too useless to do much of anything at all.”
 
It’s because they hate her
toxicitzi
BUY SOME APPLES! - Derpi Supporter
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Sapphire -
Happy Derpy! - For Patreon supporters

@ARchy4288  
see, this is why I hate good bronies myself. They make you think that just because you’re capable of feeling other emotions, they’re not genuine on account of not being the same as their own.
 
You feeling this way over Celestia isn’t just making you a waifu faggot, or something other that they would like to name it, it just means they don’t understand this sort of thing because they’ve never been involved or even bothered themselves with understanding what it means to be Creative and Create stuff that an audience can enjoy. There’s an innumerable amount of ways for someone to get immersed into a story, that’s what is so great about story telling and why it still works even today after who knows how many long centuries.
 
if they scoff at everything you’re saying no matter how articulate you make the argument, know that they’re much worse off than you are, it’s something to tell yourself whenever you think they’ve gotten at you. They’re not right about you being wrong, if so, why the hell should you the one being shaken by their shit?  
mate, I’ve seen enough bronies to know a good amount of the ones that don’t think can put you in a very bad mood, but it’s best to just mentally tell them to fuck off sometimes with that shit and maybe if you have such an opportunity, call them out on their bs.
ARchy4288

@toxicitzi  
so what you’re saying was this arc just like the show was part of them actively trying to diminish celestia she can’t be a keeper of harmony, yet the so called element bearers are far more flawed… But you know what it doesn’t matter I know my place in this fandom I know where I stand in terms of being pleased by these jerks and it’s them telling me to fuck off and die. So I will I fucking will
 
They hate celestia and are thus too fucking lazy to do anything but slander her. Fuck these comics fuck the show fuck the writers I hope they all lose their fucking jobs. Because they’re no talent celsria hating hacks…
 
Fuck it… I want to die I want to fucking die because they keep butchering her character and I keep feeling more and more alienated and nobody has ever resoectem my opinion and telling me I have no right to be angry when theyre double talking little shits. it’s boiling over and now I just want to fucking die…
ARchy4288

@toxicitzi  
@toxicitzi  
So yeah I get it it’s not like I was depressed enough already about her portrayal in the show by the lazy showrunners but to see the comics do one worse and pander to the celestia haters in the fandom and to ship her with this bland flawless and no character Gary stu was just a sucker punch. It’s as if cook was calling fans like me a pathetic loser for being attatched to celestia and showing me that I can’t even fantasize because I’m an ugly disgusting loser. And the fact that she was gonna gather criticism and make fun of people who didn’t like the arc just show that both she and price are thin skinned jerks.
 
You probably think I’m stupid right now but you know what? I really don’t give a shit. The fandom hates her he writers of the show hate her and he comic wroters hate her. I think I should just FOAD nobody here in this “love and tolerate” fandom would give a fuck.
 
Yes love and tolerate unless you’re a celestia fan who sees her as your waifu then you need to haut shut up or fuckig leave because people like that are what’s wrong with the fandom.
 
Fuck it… Just fuck it… I’m fucking sick of this shit… Everything they do of celsria just makes her look worse and worse because they just don’t give a shit…
 
but whatever I’m stupid for disliking this because of the reasons I gave I see how it is… I’m too fucking stupid to have an opinion. Fine… Thanks for letting me know what I already did. I’m not welcome in the fandom. The comics alienate me and they don’t fucking care that they lost a fan. But they got their accolades by all the “popular” fans and others like me can leave if we don’t liek it… Well I’ll fucki go leave I’ll fucking leave. I know I’m not welcome here…
 
I want to fucking die right now…
toxicitzi
BUY SOME APPLES! - Derpi Supporter
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Sapphire -
Happy Derpy! - For Patreon supporters

@ARchy4288  
There’s no evidence in the show itself that they’re following on the comics’ narrative, that’s my reason why I think comics aren’t canon regardless of what we’ve been told.
 
secondly, if it were presented like that, I would probably buy it, but it wasn’t. Brad was though, which you can plainly see in him playing absolutely no role into the story at all other than the romance itself.  
To me, it seemed as though someone’s fantasy was being written, or love life? I doubt it was the latter, but anyway, it didn’t look like a half-assed attempt at throwing in romance for no reason, it just was half-assed in tying it all together and thinking better in advance what to do with Celestia as to not make her actions contradict her implied growth, but in not doing that, they painted a completely different picture than was inferred and it’s not that Celestia is too orderly to be harmonious anymore, she is and was always too flawed to stay a keeper of harmony.
 
Also, yes, it was very disappointing to me too that someone so dignified and strongly ingrained in such serious matters and high morals is so easily shaken and swayed by temptation, all of her qualities and personality seemed very, faux at that point, like there wasn’t even one genuine emotion in any of those morals she was upholding.  
it’s really disappointing I guess if you think about it, but maybe they’ll have listened and make something much better the next time they have her center stage. One thing that I do know is that the show will never do it, 4 years is a pretty long wait for Celestia to do not just something, but literally, Anything at all.. because even those small moments amount to absolutely nothing that can tell you more about Celestia alone, probably the only exception being the season 1 opener, where her actions seemed more focused with the narrative and how she had a hand in helping with the situation, without involving herself directly in it. Everything else after that point was her being too useless to do much of anything at all.
ARchy4288

@toxicitzi  
But whatever I’m just a waifufag and this is “canon” so my opinion is automatically discredited as shit and I have no right to be angry and if I don’t like it I should kindly leave the fandom and hey, why don’t I kill myself while I’m at it.
 
After all I’m just a pathetic piece of shit for vein most upset about the shipping aspect of this awful arc.
ARchy4288

@toxicitzi  
I was saying the fact that it was more about her flaws than her wisdom was a big glaring problem. She can have flaws but they showed nothing to counterbalance them on top of that was a stupid and trite romance plot (yes I think it was just to take a shot at fans like me) and they made everything in the story her fault.
 
If you read one of my previous comments I said it could’ve been a mirrorverse of her own creation and the evil was her doubts and fears and she overcomes them through her wisdom and the love of her sister and teachings of starswirl.
 
What this arc was instead was just… Disgusting. Making her look like a selfish brat where everything was her fault and even saying that nmm was Celestia’s fault as well.
 
And I’m sorry but I honestly think that they just wanted to ship her to alienate waifufags like me. Sorry call me pathetic but there was no other reason for it.
toxicitzi
BUY SOME APPLES! - Derpi Supporter
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Sapphire -
Happy Derpy! - For Patreon supporters

@ARchy4288  
sorry, but that’s a stupid reason to get mad at people for. If anything, highlighting flaws that have to do with one’s greatest strengths is one of the most realistic lesson for everyone to learn, as the saying goes, you are your own worst enemy.
 
the one thing worth getting mad at is if the flaw in her strongest quality was ignored in favor of another different type of flaw, one that done wrong (which it was) only took away from said character.  
but that’s the others’ reactions to it, my point isn’t to say the comic is great or bad, I think it was at the very least trying something other than a mundane and equally as insipid story, what I’m saying is that highlighting someone’s flaws isn’t something to scoff at. That’s how character development happens, or in this case, some character depth for one character everyone’s been very curious about.
 
At least it’s better than the canon one in that it did honestly try to tell us something about Celestia, as Sunset was a severely wasted opportunity.  
Some say it’s better to keep it all a mystery than to mess up and try, I don’t buy into it, I’m of the opinion that if you keep it a mystery for much longer than necessary, you have the effect of that initial interest growing stale, as well as the interest in that character, I would know, because Blizzard did the same thing for over 10 fucking years with their universe and you know what?.. it’s not better, it’s in fact much worse and I stopped caring 4 years ago so much that their story telling ability is so dead to me, it’s been buried deep into the ground already.