That’s true. Sometimes I wonder what exactly Discord whispered to them…“turn them to stone for a while”, for example, without mentioning that he intended it to be forever with his added magic. I’d like to think that Luna wouldn’t be so vindictive as to think eternal punishment was “fitting”, especially after her own experience, but again, emotions were running high at that moment.

Well, fate of those three is Celestia’s and Luna’s decision.

It would be nice to think that after the dust settled and emotions calmed, the Princesses realized that they had made a serious mistake in listening to Discord, and started working with Twilight to make things right.

@Background Pony #9DBD  
The first three had potential at the end of Frienemies, but as I said, Discord willfully snuffed it.

No foe too irredeemable, except Chrysalis, Tirek, Cozy Glow, King Sombra, The Storm King, Lightning Dust, Iron Will, Flim and Flam, Svengallop, Wind Rider, and most importantly, Feather Bangs.

@northern haste  
Josh Haber was the story editor for the last 13 episodes of Season 9, so a lot of how the overall plot wrapped up is his fault. https://mlp.fandom.com/wiki/Josh_Haber

@Smart Heart  
True enough. Thanks a lot, Discord.

@Whistle Blossom  
If they were irredeemable, it’s thanks to Discord.

I… hate to agree with this.

hmmmmmmmmmmmmm

@Background Pony #F7BD  
Based

Pony Life Twilight’s “No foe left unredeemed” line was an interesting one, and as much as I’d enjoy seeing Chrysalis return in PL, I don’t know if the producers would go there.

Based alt. universe Twilight. Much better than G4 version.

@Background Pony #F7BD  
Okay seasonwunner

A hmmmmm indeed

@Background Pony #F7BD  
All seasons are canon and Haber didn’t even write that episode

Two things:  
Haber’s fanfiction, aka S8 and S9, is not canon.  
Pony Life is not canon.

@Background Pony #6062  
Or you should to not take everything what she says too literally. I don’t know it’s a joke or not, but I think it shouldn’t be tagged with hypocrisy, regardless it’s canon or not.

And then people wood complain about them getting reformed

When you realize that FIM and Pony Life are two separate things and not related to one another

Pony life isn’t canon. Twilight can’t be a hypocrite in this case in particular.

She did say it…