Viewing last 25 versions of comment by AC97 on image #2170331

AC97
Lunar Supporter - Helped forge New Lunar Republic's freedom in the face of the Solar Empire's oppressive tyrannical regime (April Fools 2023).
Non-Fungible Trixie -
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition

"[@Background Pony #ACBE":](/images/2170331#comment_8902694

[bq]
)
 

>
Celestia lived over 1000 years 'cause of age magic

 
*
[/bq]

_[
citation needed]_

*
 
That's fanon.

[bq]

 

>
then it should be obvious Alicorns aren't automatically immortal.[/bq]



 
Why would it be "obvious?" We hadn't seen an alicorn show signs of aging past their prime once, and they never went out of their way to explain why, in the show.

"They explicitly stated Discord is immortal" is not an argument for the lack thereof.
 
Whether you like it or not, it's not self-evident that they aren't ageless, and you have a better case for the opposite, when three out of five alicorns (thus meaning the majority) have shown no signs of aging past their prime (Luna is Celestia's younger sister, and Horse Play placed the timeline of Nightmare Moon probably at least one hundred years after Celestia first raised the sun ["The one-thousand, one-hundred, eleventh year anniversary of when you first raised the sun." - Twilight]... so unless she's just so much younger than Celestia, they were at least a century old when that happened, each, unless you'll move the goalposts by saying Luna _*obviously_* used age magic too), where other ponies have aged (Twilight's friends).


 
Now, do I consider them "gods?" No. They're closer to falling under "demigods," if anything, since they can presumably die, for one thing.
No reason given
Edited by AC97
AC97
Lunar Supporter - Helped forge New Lunar Republic's freedom in the face of the Solar Empire's oppressive tyrannical regime (April Fools 2023).
Non-Fungible Trixie -
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition

"@Background Pony #ACBE":/images/2170331#comment_8902694

[bq]Celestia lived over 1000 years 'cause of age magic[/bq]

_[citation needed]_

That's fanon.

[bq]then it should be obvious Alicorns aren't automatically immortal.[/bq]

Why would it be "obvious?" We hadn't seen an alicorn show signs of aging past their prime once, and they never went out of their way to explain why, in the show.

Whether you like it or not, it's not self-evident that they aren't ageless, and you have a better case for the opposite, when three out of five alicorns (thus meaning the majority) have shown no signs of aging past their prime (Luna is Celestia's younger sister, and Horse Play placed the timeline of Nightmare Moon probably at least one hundred years after Celestia first raised the sun ["The one-thousand, one-hundred, eleventh year anniversary of when you first raised the sun." - Twilight]... so unless she's just so much younger than Celestia, they were at least a century old when that happened, each, unless you'll move the goalposts by saying Luna _obviously_ used age magic too), where other ponies have aged (Twilight's friends).

Now, do I consider them "gods?" No. They're closer to falling under "demigods," if anything, since they can presumably die, for one thing.
No reason given
Edited by AC97