@NLTLF  

@genervt
 
it just so happens to be the same reason she’s such a pain in the ass

@NLTLF  
But I do.  
There is a reason Trixie is a fan favorite.

@genervt  

 
yeah, i don’t think so

@NLTLF  
Saving Equestria, supporting Glimmy, being hilarious, making every episode she is in better.

@genervt
 
only when corrupted. otherwise i don’t even remember what she could do because her act is so forgettable

@NLTLF  
Trixie is a Great and Powerful character.

@genervt
 
trixie is not a good character.

@NLTLF  
No.  
She lost all her possessions before thanks to two certain geniuses.  
Also corruption.

@genervt
 
trixie getting comeuppance is okay tho

@NLTLF  
No.  
One simply does not silence the Great and Powerful Trixie.  
And Pinkie would never make other Ponies unhappy.

@genervt
 
yeah it is

This is not ok.

For all I know, Pinkie likes Trixie the most out of the mane 6…so this drawing is stretching it.

@Ltmajordude  
His logic is kinda shitty honestly, he’s saying he wants characters to basically get stale and to never change which would make a terrible show since most villains appear often or multiple times; take a series like DBZ/S where rarely does a villain return with the exact same strategy or actions, hell Freeiza(one of the greatest anime villains) progressed to a role that made him chaotic neutral while keeping his usual villainous personality and tone. Better yet think Vegeta, had he followed this guy’s logic he wouldn’t be the antihero he is after gaining a new perspective

@Background Pony #5263  
Technically she’s not redeemed, she’s just not actively attempting to cause trouble; that’s what almost every redemption is, a character stops being extremely malicious. Discord in “a matter of Principle” is a perfect example of how redemption doesn’t affect personality only how the act toward the main cast/“good guys”

the redeemed version of her is still obnoxious and unlikable

 
I never thought I see the day when an actual brony hates Sunset Shimmer.  
:|