Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Techy Cutie Pony Collection!

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

I mean what the fudge?!
 
This book will have Twilight, cheat on Timber, or at least be very tempted to do so, with a guy, she possibly knows for an hour or maybe minutes (Celestia, I really hope not minutes).
 
I mean, I and others wrote the writers wrote Sci-Twi, when she romances people, (arguably) behaves like a stereotypical lovestruck teen, and behaves Out of Character, but this (possibly) reaches a new level of bad in this case.
 
I and from what I see, others, really hope Twilight will be under a literal spell of Rising Star, but it can be he just made Twilight fall for him with his charisma, in which case (which is the worst), this would be some really visible character derailment.
 
And Really, the first male villain in Equestria Girls, and he’s a seducer type villain, who blatantly tries/seduces Sci-Twi? This is really how they will portray the first real male antagonist? As seemingly a stereotypical Femme Fatale, just gender-bent?
 
I mean, yes, the writing on guys wasn’t really good in Equestria Girls, but this reaches a new high.
 
I really hope this book won’t have an animated counterpart, and something in latter Equestria Girls animations will contradict it.
 
But even with that, I feel this leave bad effects in the fandom/bad aftertaste in the fandom. Again, how it handles the first direct male antagonist, and how it will probably make a number of people stereotype Sci-Twi (even if she is under a spell), mockingly or seriously, as boy crazy teen, or Bella (from Twilight) type character…
 
Dunno, maybe I’m overreacting, but if this is an indication of things to come, this may be a quite bad direction to take Equestria Girls. (or at least I think so)
 
(Vector by luckreza8 , here and here
 
Noticed this problem thanks to the comments under >>1656767 )

safe2267101 artist:ritalux110 editor:backgroundlol19 flash sentry15452 neon lights1054 rising star1054 sci-twi32729 twilight sparkle371238 canterlot high stories23 equestria girls267810 g42126456 my little pony equestria girls: legend of everfree8959 my little pony: equestria girls: canterlot high stories: twilight sparkle's science fair sparks16 official14386 amazon.com231 book45859 camp everfree outfits2339 discussion in the comments842 drama3356 scared14933 screaming5136

Comments

Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide

Background Pony #526E
Background Pony #4264 don’t hope this book will be a awesome movie Becouse Hasbro make it so they will decide whether it is a movie and it will be awesome to be a awesome movie so there.
Background Pony #526E
Hasbro will decide whether it will be a awesome movie or special for this book because it’s Hasbro disution Background Pony #4264 so don’t hope this won’t be Becouse Equestria girls belongs to Hasbro and they will decide whether it is a movie and would be happy to hear it will be.
Background Pony #4FE6
it will not be like an episode nor special neither. it will only be a simple book.
BackgroundLoL
Fine Arts - Two hundred uploads with a score of over a hundred (Safe/Suggestive)

@Background Pony #D6F8  
Eeeh, that comment has over a month, and was pretty much out of context…
 
…not to be rude, but I’m just really not sure it’s worth restarting this discussion, over something so unrelated to the rest of the discussion, and having such a potential to cause a rather…messy new discussion.
Background Pony #0D78
@BackgroundLoL Pony #3A99”:/1656888#comment_6905134  
Don’t compare with fluttercord they never have romance. Discord is a old man and fluttershy are best friends and was friendship. Is very different and was friendship canon
BackgroundLoL
Fine Arts - Two hundred uploads with a score of over a hundred (Safe/Suggestive)

@Esteban
 
Somehow multiple people read my comments, or escription, and commented on it. Like you know, even you. But I guess you exactly the type of person who “rejects reality and substitutes it with their own” and/or insane troll logic (along with as I mentioned, being a major hippocrite of course)
 
And I alleeady feel you will comment all people who responded to my comment, or description, are just my other accounts. But I guess that even includes now you being just another alternate account of mine, and this whole argument of us is just to create of a pretense of us being separate people XD
BackgroundLoL
Fine Arts - Two hundred uploads with a score of over a hundred (Safe/Suggestive)

@Esteban  
Jesus, you are the person who went on an insane rant, claiming everyone who ho agreed with me/disagreed with you is me. Talk about hippocrisy.
 
And for several commets, you stopped using any pretense of arguments, and are just attacking me.
 
If anyone is to stop a pointless rant, it’s you.
BackgroundLoL
Fine Arts - Two hundred uploads with a score of over a hundred (Safe/Suggestive)

@Esteban  
So you do claim Alexlayer, Darth Shy, Background Pony #C543, and MaresFillies are also me? Even though Alexlayer had been here for 5 years, and Mares Files had one for 4 years.
 
I don’t think yiu have the right to call others “obessive”, seeing you now have paranoia everyone who agrees with me/disagrees with you is me. And talk about projection - your multiple ad hominem’s are obviously you venting your frustration you cannot create any reall counterarguments by this point. At least o it comes of if you only attack me, and claim everyone is me.
 
And you failed to mention one example of there being a comparable contradiction to the one this book has with canon - you only stated one assumption, then started to just attack me, my motives, and now making borderline insane looikng claims.
 
And as I mentioned, all of this is still a false equivalence - @BackgroundLoL  
@Esteban
And your example is not only wrong (due to mistaking assumptions, for canon), as mentioned by Background Pony #3A99, your whole argument is based on false assumptions - the two episodes, had the same, primary/1st place level of canon, and as a rule, all secondary canon (like books or comics), are overriden and rendered noncanon by primary/1st place canon/animated works.
Like (as mentioned bwllow) with the Fiendship is Magic comic prequell about Sirens and Star Swirl, being overriden by telling of the Dazzlings sending to the human world by Star Swirl in season 7. Or how Moondancer was a very different, and different aged character, than shown in the cartoon, i the comics, and cartoon Moondancer is canon.
The only difference is that Twilight Sparkle’s Science Fair Sparks writes itself in the first place with stary that is contradicted by prmary canon.
I don’t want to go into arguable ad hominem, as Background Pony #3A99 suggested you did, but if anything, you come of as overly defensive (for some reason), of this book’s canonicity.
I apolognize if it’s not the case, but as of now, you essentially argue this book should be an exception to rules, that pretty much governed all other works, and their canonicity….
 
This is something you didn’t adress, just preffered to attack me.
Esteban
Duck - "You would all have 10/10 episodes if i was responsible for this season as story editor and I could do it for free"

@BackgroundLoL  
There is no discussin. Just you venting your frustration and accidental people like me being cought up with it and either being amused by it or annoyed like in my case. There a ton of continuity issues with the series itself, not to mention movies, EQG and comics. If you want create an outrage in the fandom to denounce the canonicity of this book then you will have to create couple more accounts.
BackgroundLoL
Fine Arts - Two hundred uploads with a score of over a hundred (Safe/Suggestive)

@Esteban
 
And yet again, another ad hominem.
 
And you are aware I disagreed with Background Pony #3A99 (at least twice if I rememer right), and just critized them?
 
Not to mention, can’t you accept we critized you similary, as you know, you just did do that suff? (like you knoe, mistaking your headcanon about episodes, with canon? And hipocritically accusing others of using headcanon?)
 
And what further, will you claim the 8 people who favorites this picture, and 13 who upvoted it, are also me?
 
Or MaresFillies who also joked it’s as non canon as the comics, is another of my alternate accounts?
 
That Darth Shy, who also at the start of the discussion, stated she would be good if this book turned out to be non canon is also me?
 
Or that everyone who agreed with me in some way - Alexlayer, Darth Shy, Background Pony #C543, MaresFillies, are my alternate accounts?
 
I guess I have tons of free time, and I am legion XD
 
But seriosly, if you want to discuss things, please start again using reall arguments, than just attacking my person or motives.