Kerosene, matches, and the Blu Ray release of Reservoir Dogs.

@TheLoneLampman
 
You beat me to it, but I was gonna say a bag of candy, chloroform, and a pair of handcuffs.

toothpaste, deodorant, and shampoo

An apple, Mass Effect 3, and a Hallmark gift card.
 
Which all fit into my fetishes.

Candy, Nyquil, and Duct tape.

Hunting knife, bleach, and a copy of I Am Legend on dvd.

A knife, stain remover and a shovel

A pony toy, rope, and panties in a size appropriate for a girl under 10 years old.

Chloroform, a pregnancy test, and a box of diapers.

Alright, instead of KY Jelly how about some IcyHot.

bleach, rope, and a shovel

Lotion, Banana and Alcohol.
 
Tho random has the same idea I suppose.

Read the bottom. Lube is not allowed.

>latex gloves  
>mexican coke  
>crisco

A tube of KY Jelly  
A single banana  
and a pair of hancuffs.