Ah,the existential question…

@wozzledozzle  
Hahahahaha.

… Fascinating.  
I’m going to say….  
Yes.
 
We fell in love with these characters as ponies. Even if they are drawn as humans.
 
They would just be random OC’s to us  
without the ponies we’ve come to know and care about enough that they can make us feel… that way. But I’m sure most everyone here can look at a humanized drawing and immediately know which pony they are!
 
AJ is AJ; Twi is Twi, Derpy is Derpy!, weather they’re drawn as a pony, antro, or human!

Yes.

It’s flop

it is porn if humanized.

@Background Pony  
Well, Doctor Whooves is (fanonically) based on The Doctor, but there are different ways of distinguish him, such as the hourglass Cutie Mark, blue eyes, no sideburns, and a different haircut. Maybe also slightly different clothes, and you can make him Asian\Hispanic\Middle Eastern\Indian\Native American\Pacific Islander\Black\Aboriginal\a gypsy\Inuit\Filipino\Thai\ambiguosly brown to differentiate.

I’m gonna say no…
 
 
@legalese  
I’m not. But I don’t judge.

@lasty  
the better question is: what is it if you base your pony on a real human then humanize it but don’t really make it look like the human it was originally based on?

@ArmyBoy57  
FIRST thing I thought of. RIP ghostler.

@gasmaskangel  
“complely different orifices” I meant to say.

@Background Pony  
Well for starting they do not have the same result as pooping is the end result of eating, secondly they involve completely orifices, thirdly one involves the intake of nutrients and the other the expelling of waste, and fourth they hopefully don’t take place in the same room.
 
By contrast everything about clopping and regular masturbation is exactly the same aside from the subject matter and dildo color.

Yes. Now go write your newsletter.

Is it caption
 
if it’s a screenshot with text?

I’d call it western hentai.

Use the damn forums!  
And anyway, no.  
It’s the usual fapping.

Is it fapping if you ponify a human?

@legalese  
Speak for yourself. If I fap to anything pony related, they are at least human. I don’t consider human based images ‘clop’.

@Background Pony  
That is a horrifying yet correct statement.

no, but we’re all cloppers here anyway, so it doesn’t really matter.

@gasmaskangel  
Eating and pooping. why differentiate? the end result is the same.

I classify all MLP porn as clop even if it’s humanized.

Does it really matter? I mean the end result is the same.

no it is hmop