@Phantom Rider  
That sounds like her. :)

@The Dark Pony  
Rares would turn the most exquisite shade of green, and offer her some clean clothes. :D

@Phantom Rider  
Yeah, I find it hard to imagine even Rarity would turn on one of her friends for it, even though she’d still be disgusted by the mess itself.

I like some embarrassment too, but not extreme. As for the other characters not being fine with it, well, your best friends, if they’re good ones, wouldn’t treat you too badly because you were having tummy troubles. Concern for your health if you were in extreme pain leading up to it beyond simply ‘gotta go,’ good-natured ribbing otherwise, maybe.

@Background Pony #1777  
That is also fun to think about.

@The Dark Pony  
I also like embarrassment here and there, like maybe Sunset scratching the back of her neck sheepishly after soiling herself, as her friends hold their noses.
 
I also don’t want it to last either, maybe as a little jab here and there in future like  
“Heh, Hey Sunny, remember that time you deuced your pants at the mall?”  
But nothing that would ruin her life, it’s all in light hearted fun. Banter can be really fun to write.

@Background Pony #1777  
All good. I know we all have our own preferences with this kind of thing. Some really love the humiliation, some aren’t into it. I’m sorta in-between - the humiliation factor can be fun (in fiction only) but I don’t want it to last.

@The Dark Pony  
fair enough, just thought I’d ask cause I was curious

@Background Pony #1777  
Well, I mean, of course I’ve done ones where the ones wetting or messing themselves are embarrassed about it, as that’s always the expected reaction, and if you mean whoever’s around, I usually like them feeling better about it afterwards even if there’s humiliation at first, and there’s no chance of that if their friends turn on them for it. I know Rarity would likely be disgusted to witness Twi or anyone else soiling herself, but more for the mess/smell itself, and probably feel bad for her if it was accidental.
 
As for ones I’ve done where they do it deliberately or otherwise enjoy it or simply don’t mind and/or it becomes something casual that happens often enough… I really like the idea of that, even though obviously I’d be super embarrassed at wetting or messing myself in front of anyone and take great effort not to do so.

Do you think you’d ever do some edits where none of the characters are fine with it? When soiling is treated as taboo as it is IRL, scenarios like this could potentially be a lot more interesting.
 
Granted, of course, it all comes down to personal preference. But hey, the idea is there if you want to give it a shot.