Neutral Evil for Rampage? Seriously? Maybe I don’t understand these classifications but that seems wrong.  
Highly protective of foals.  
Protective of her friends.  
Even cares enough to give Blackjack advice, even knowing she more than likely won’t listen.  
EVEN when she betrayed Blackjack after Cog-Sucker promised to end her life, Rampage didn’t want to kill BJ.
 
These don’t seem like the characteristics of an evil person. A neutral evil person would have killed Blackjack without hesitation when she refused to join the Reapers or when they were promised the one thing they could never obtain, death.

An updated version: >>2040624

I’m not 100% on the choices, but I think I want this on my wall

@Cylindryk1  
I tried my best. (And I didn’t get past chapter 20 of PH)

Selecting LittlePip as Lawful Good? As any kind of “good”?  
And Rampage is Evil?  
Are you sure you read both stories? If anything, that should at least be exchanged…

>trying to label any of these incredibly flawed and intricately developed characters as one alignment or another  
Like, you did pretty good, I think you got as close as is feasible with the given ponies, but most everypony here could arguably fit at least two other alignments.

I always pegged Calamity as a Lawful Good for his ‘see-raider-shoot-raider’ policy. I think Littlepip could be moved over to Neutral Good because she’s willing to make exceptions to the rules she lives by (for instance: taking a mintal to convince Red Eye to relocate his balefire bomb; lying and killing Autumn Leaf). And Homage can take the place of Lawful Neutral instead, for her generally unbiased reporting, as evident in the Arbu incident (“Bringing you the truth, no matter how bad it hurts.”)

@infinita est lux Solis  
I got it: Shadow, from Fall of Hope. If there’s someone that even comes close, it’s him.  
_{Man I wish that fanfic updated already.}

@Fingusa  
Such as?

@infinita est lux Solis  
She also caused more death in a small amount of time than anyone else in the story.
 
Also she nuked the world, again.
 
We cannot even say that she becomes this at the end of the story cause of the ultimate sacrifice cause in the end she does it mostly to not face the consequences of her own actions.
 
Again, its just my personal opinion but it feels like there is a much better pick for lawful good somewhere among the FoE stories.

@Fingusa  
Well, I had to fill the spaces, and they seemed to fit the best. I chose Pip for LG because her end goal was to restore law and order, despite being a murder hobo herself.

Well lets do this.
 
I honestly do not think there is anyone lawful good in the Wasteland, cause nobody really respects any laws. Especially not Pippy who is basically just a murder hobo in the end. Hell, maybe Homage counts cause she just reports the news with disregard to bias… mostly.
 
I really do not think Calamity counts as lawful neutral, or at least not by the end of the story. He is 100% a biased good guy. Probably chaotic good.
 
Rampage being evil is silly. Maybe one of her personalities is chaotic evil and that is only till she comes to terms with that. If anything, for the majority of the story, she should be somewhere on the neutral scale.

>liddlbib  
>lawful  
>good  
Topokeko